Archaeologists and Journalists: Please Stop Finding the Garden of Eden!

Posted in: Archaeology and Bible, Archaeology and Media, Archaeology in the News, Bible and Media
Tags: archaeology news, biblical archaeology, biblical literature
Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+

Contributed by Michael M. Homan, Xavier University of Louisiana.

I just read that they found the Garden of Eden again. It seems to have moved from its previous locations in Bahrain, Yemen, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and Jerusalem. The latest location of chez Adam & Eve is at Gobekli Tepe. While it is truly an amazing site with great implications for understanding the Neolithic Revolution, it’s not Paradise.

So why the skepticism? Simply put, the story of the Garden of Eden is a myth.

The Center Panel (Paradise) of the Garden of Earthly Delights by Hieronymous Bosch

The Bible offers a couple of clues about the location of Eden. Cain was kicked out of Eden eastward to Nod (Gen 4:16). However, ‘Nod’ is derived from a root that means “to wander,” so it’s not a specific location, but indicates that Cain will be a fugitive. The best evidence for Eden’s location is that a river in Eden broke into four rivers: 1) the Pishon, 2) Gihon, 3) Hiddekel, and 4) Ferat (Gen 2:10-14). The identity of the last two is certain, being the Tigris and Euphrates respectively. Nevertheless, a wide range of possibilities for the other two prohibits a definitive location. The river Pishon is said to be located in the land of Havilah where there is quality gold, bdellium and onyx stone (2:11-12). Havilah is alternatively located in 1) Nubia, with the Pishon being the Nile, 2) India, with river candidates being the Indus or Ganges, or 3) Southwest Arabia, with the Pishon being the Wadi Bisha and the Wadi Baish. All three areas are famous for gold and the other commodities. Similar confusion surrounds the identification of the Gihon River. Gihon comes from a root meaning “to gush forth,” and thus it is a common name for flowing bodies of water throughout the ancient Near East. The Bible qualifies Eden’s Gihon as a river that flows around the land of Cush (2:13). Confusion persists, however, as there are in fact two areas named Cush in the Bible, the first and more famous being Nubia, and thus the Gihon would refer to the Nile River. The second area for biblical Cush is in Midian, with a number of wadis and streams serving as candidates. The great biblical scholar and archaeologist William Albright thought that the Pishon and Gihon were the two branches of the Nile River, known today as the Blue Nile and the White Nile. Alternatively, some have claimed this River Gihon is the famous spring in Jerusalem’s Kidron Valley, thus linking the Garden of Eden to the Temple in Jerusalem. Nevertheless, this remains unlikely, as the argument ignores the correspondence of Eden’s Gihon to the land of Cush, a term never used in conjunction with Jerusalem. The early Jewish Historian Josephus identified the Pishon with the Ganges and the Gihon with the Nile. In doing so, Eden is positioned at the source of the ancient Near East’s four largest rivers. Thus, it’s not a realistic location that you could visit, but instead, it is a mythological place which brings fertility in the form of river water to the entire world known to the biblical authors.

And to close here is Marge Simpson’s dream about Eden, but sadly, it cuts off before the butterscotch pond and the porno bush:

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+
4 Comments for : Archaeologists and Journalists: Please Stop Finding the Garden of Eden!
  1. Pingback: Higgaion » Eden, ASOR, and Hieronymus Bosch

    • עיצ
    • September 14, 2012

    כל עיצוב שתרצו אנו מסוגלים לעצב או לסגל לטעמכם האינדיווידואלי ולבקשותיכם.

    • Sue wiese
    • January 29, 2017

    If the Garden of Eden is a Myth, then YOU are a myth.

  2. Pingback: Garden Of Eden And Its Four Rivers – Possible Locations Of Biblical Paradise Suggested By Archaeologists, Historians And Biblical Scholars - Ancient Pages

Leave a Comment cancel

Tweets by @AmerSchOrietRes
Buy ASOR Merchandise
2017 ASOR Archives Calendar
2017 ASOR Archives Calendar
by ASOResearch
ASOR 11oz Classic Mug
ASOR 11oz Classic Mug
by ASOResearch

RSS Friends of ASOR Podcast

  • Gender in Ancient Egypt: Norms, Ambiguities, and Sensualities
  • Reduced to Her Bare Essentials: Bronze Age Piriform Pendants in the Levant
  • Engendering the Israelite Harvests with Jennie Ebeling
  • Sex Crimes in the Laws of the Hebrew Bible
  • Crime and Sexual Offense in Hatti
Sign in to view all ASOR Blog content!
If you have not set up a username and password for the ASOR Blog, please close this box by clicking anywhere on the screen then go to the Friends of ASOR option in the menu above. If you have forgotten your password, please click the Forgot Login Password option in the above menu.